Legionnaires’ Disease: Person-to-Person Transmission
Legionnaires’ disease in Portugal
However, one case of Legionnaires’ disease that occurred in Portugal has led the medical community to question whether person-to-person transmission may be possible after all.
The case in question occurred in November 2014, when an adult male was found to be one of a cluster of people suffering from Legionnaires’ disease. The outbreak occurred in Vila Franca de Xira, and a subsequent investigation showed that a cooling tower complex was ultimately responsible for the outbreak of Legionnaires’ disease.
300 kilometres from the outbreak
Whilst very unfortunate, the fact that the adult male was infected by Legionella bacteria was not too a big surprise. He was a maintenance worker at the Vila Franca de Xira site that was found to be the epicentre of the outbreak. However, the man’s mother also later developed symptoms of Legionnaires’ disease – despite the fact she had been nowhere near the problem cooling towers at any time. She had in fact been around 300km away, living in a house with her son. That number of kilometres equates to approximately 186 miles – quite a distance for the bacteria to travel of its own accord.
Clearly, in this case, the obvious thought is that she contracted the disease from her son. She cared for her son during his illness, and sadly both she and her son later died following complications arising from Legionnaires’ disease.
Possible person-to-person transmission of Legionnaires’
Various areas of the house they lived in were swabbed for analysis. However, there were no signs of any Legionella bacteria anywhere. This led investigators to surmise that the logical source of the woman’s infection was indeed person-to-person transmission from her son.
As we now know, the official line is currently that Legionnaires’ disease is not spread through person-to-person contact. However, as this case seems to have proven, this is not entirely the case. It could well be that this form of transmission from one person to another is exceedingly rare.
Does close proximity matter?
The conditions that were present in this case – the close contact, the fact the son was very ill, and the small, relatively confined space in which possible contamination may have occurred – could all have led to the possibility becoming true in this case. In addition, the room was not ventilated in any way, further suggesting the possibility that contamination in close unventilated quarters could be possible after all.
Clearly, further research into this area is definitely required.
Expert Legionella risk management support
To find out more about our expert Legionella risk management support services please contact us on 0161 877 0586 (Manchester) or 0203 637 47 48 (London).
152 City Road
London EC1V 2NX
Tel: +44 (0) 203 637 47 48
Unit B Badex Building
Manchester M17 1AY
Tel: +44 (0) 161 877 0586
For additional information about Legionnaires’ disease diagnosis … here